Right, Tina was said to have gone to bed prior to the boys, Sue being the last awake prior to the killers coming in. We still don't know when Johnny and Dana came home, but it's plausible they were either hanging out in his downstairs room and came up when they heard the fighting, or just walked in on it. 'Disappearing' from 930 until 130ish, with no known ride home, tells me they were probably downstairs when it began. With cardboard covering Johnny's BR windows, it would have been difficult to detect lights on in the room.
As for Justin's statements, many of them fly in the face of reality. The best bet is to believe most in his earliest statements, which were either not documented, or stolen by Josh or one of the pigs, or simply never made public. The more Justin was around Marty's bestie pal, Sheriff Sylvester Thomas, the more filled with BS his stories became. I'm pretty sure Justin's shift is primarily a defensive move to protect himself from Marty's drug-dealing PCSO Pals. Still, there is a consistent thread from Justin that Tina was "down by the river" and LE "didn't look hard enough" for Tina there, and these were made and remembered by others before Loon got the chance to manipulate Justin's memories. Also, Alysa Seabolt found the pink clothing (jumpsuit, night clothes, sweat suit?) which PCSO seem to have successfully tied back to being Tina's. Also, of course, Marty said had HE killed them, he would have taken Tina across the swinging bridge, next to the "swimming hole". Which is exactly what they did, I believe.
Justin did also say Tina came out of the bedroom with a blanket, saying "what's going on?", which I believe is BS. All evidence points to blood first being spilled in the bedroom, and there's simply no way Tina slept through it. Nobody slept through it, pure and simple. Which takes us, full circle, to the first post in this thread:
"Marty probably told him (Justin) to come back in here and shut the door...."
The boys were awake, so this could mean Rick is actually recalling Justin going from the boys' room into the living room, or being provoked to do so, then coming back and closing the door behind him.
Short answer: Everything suggest Josh wasted our time for years, letting us assume Sue was asleep on the couch, when he had stolen evidence proving otherwise. With blood on clothing, cardboard, the bedroom door, the wall, and the bedding, there is nothing to suggest Tina was anywhere but in the small bed, and was attacked alongside her mom.
"Back off, man. I'm a scientist."
reach me at
keddie28 AT gmail DOT com